On this page
- The Act governs partition cases filed on or after January 1, 2023 over property held as tenants in common, when no written agreement binding all the co-owners governs partition.
- All the co-owners can agree in writing to take their case out of it. Otherwise it controls wherever it conflicts with the older partition rules.
- The court sets the building's value first. Co-owners who did not ask for a sale then get the first chance to buy out those who did, and several buyers share the purchase in proportion to what each already owns.
- Buyers pay into court by a date the court sets, at least 60 days after its notice of who is buying.
- A sale, if one comes, is on the open market through a California-licensed broker, listed at no less than the court's value, unless the court finds sealed bids or an auction more economically advantageous.
Does the Act apply to your family's case?
It applies when the case was filed on or after January 1, 2023, the heirs hold the building as tenants in common, and no written agreement binding all of them governs how it may be partitioned. Code of Civil Procedure section 874.311 sets those conditions.
Check the vesting before you count on any of it. The recorded deed, or the court order that distributed the building out of the estate, says how the heirs hold title. If the heirs ever signed a co-ownership agreement that covers partition, read it with the attorney, because that is the kind of agreement the Act steps aside for.
The co-owners can also opt out together. Under section 874.313, the building is partitioned under the Act unless all of them agree otherwise in writing. Where the Act does apply, it adds to the general partition statute and overrides any part of it that conflicts.
What did the Act change?
The general statute still lets a court order a sale when the owners agree to one or when a sale would be more equitable than dividing the property. The Act puts its own steps in front of that, in a fixed order, and each one gives a co-owner who wants to keep the building a chance to do so before any sale.
| Stage | What the Act requires |
|---|---|
| Value | The court fixes the value of the whole building first, normally by appraisal, unless every co-owner agrees on a value |
| Buyout | Co-owners who did not ask for a sale can buy out those who did, at that value times each share |
| Division | If the buyout does not settle it, the court divides the property unless that would cause great prejudice to the co-owners as a group |
| Sale | A sale goes to the open market by default, through a licensed broker, at a price no lower than the court's value |
Heirs who are still talking can do all of this without a judge. A buyout or a sale the family agrees on can use the same arithmetic and spares everyone the filings and the months.
How does the buyout work, step by step?
Once the value is fixed, the court sends notice that the co-owners who did not ask for a sale may buy out all of those who did. From there, section 874.317 runs on dates of its own:
- Within 45 days of that notice, any co-owner who did not ask for a sale can elect to buy all the interests of those who did.
- If only one co-owner elects, the court tells every party so. If more than one elects, the court splits the purchase among them by what each already owns, as a fraction of what all the electing co-owners own together, and sends notice of the price each one pays.
- In both cases, the court then sets a payment date at least 60 days after its notice, and each buyer pays their part of the price into the court by then.
- If some buyers pay and others do not, anyone who paid has 20 days after the court's next notice to take over the unpaid part, by paying the entire price of it into the court.
Take made-up numbers. Four siblings each own 25 percent, and the court values the building at $2,400,000. One sister asks for a sale, so her share costs $2,400,000 times 25 percent, or $600,000. Two of her brothers elect to buy. Each owns 25 percent of the 50 percent the two of them hold together, so each takes half of her share and pays $300,000. After they pay, each brother owns 37.5 percent, and the sibling who stayed out keeps 25 percent.
Arrange the money before you elect. The 60 days are a minimum, the court picks the actual date, and a loan to buy a sibling's share takes its own time to put together. If the buyers do not pay in full, the shares of the co-owners who asked for a sale are not all bought, and the case moves to the next stage.
When does the court divide the building instead of selling it?
Division is where the court starts once the buyout has run its course without taking in every co-owner who wanted a sale, or while a co-owner who asked for a division is still in the case. Under section 874.318, the court orders a division unless, after weighing the factors in section 874.319, it finds that dividing the property would cause great prejudice to the co-owners as a group.
The factors reach past the numbers. Section 874.319 tells the court to consider, among others, a co-owner's sentimental attachment to the property, including attachment that comes from the property having ancestral or other special value to that person. A family that has held a building for two generations can put that history in front of the judge.
For a single apartment building on one lot, ask the attorney early how a division could even be drawn, because that answer shapes whether the case ends in a division or a sale. Where division is ruled out, the case heads to a sale, unless no co-owner ever asked for one, and then the court dismisses it.
How is the building sold under the Act?
The Act starts from an open-market sale. Section 874.320 makes that the default and allows sealed bids or an auction only when the court finds one of them more economically advantageous for the co-owners as a group.
The co-owners get the first say on who sells it. If they agree on a real estate broker licensed in California within 10 days after the court enters its order, the court appoints that broker and sets a reasonable commission. If they cannot agree, the court appoints a disinterested California broker and sets the commission itself. Ten days is a short window for a family already in court, so talk about the broker before the order is entered.
Whoever is appointed has to offer the building in a commercially reasonable manner, at a price no lower than the value the court determined, on terms the court sets. The broker then reports to the court within seven days of receiving an offer at or above that value.
The court's value is where the listing starts, not a promised price. If no offer at that value comes in within a reasonable time, the court holds a hearing and can approve the highest offer on the table, set a new value and keep the building on the market, or order sealed bids or an auction.
A partition case is a lawsuit among relatives, and each heir in one needs a lawyer of their own. Shaya is not a lawyer and cannot advise on the case. Before anything is filed, he can give the family a current estimate of what the building would sell for, which is the same question the court's appraiser will be asked.